• Register
Click on Register and join the conversation/discussions. Give your opinions and please go to the Rules page for detailed and guidelines of the site.....

Donate to ItsBoxOffice

More Info
All the articles/images published here are copyrighted to their respective owners. No copyright infringement is ever intended by the webmaster or the community members, and if there is an issue with the content posted in the Discussion forum please email us at indianboxofficeonline @ gmail [dot] com  
15 Online
0 Member And 15 Guest
+5 votes
As we know as of now only one strong contender for hgoty in 2018 is TOH but wait if rumour mills to be believed then Race 3 is coming to give tough time to thugs for hgoty in 2018 , if Salman gives his nod to race 3 then this movie will have a strong chance to be hgoty beating thugs ,and top on that compilation for hgoty next year gonna very tough between race 3 vs thugs while so called 3rd contender Dwarf won't be in the race any more coz dwarf won't get solo release anymore . So now give your honest opinions over race 3 vs thugs
asked in Box Office Related by Casting Director (17.9k points)
75% Accept Rate

10 Answers

+2 votes

Salman will make race3 really cool but honestly I never liked this franchisee. I liked the first movie in parts but the second was bad. I will still say toh for hgoty. Aamir khan plus yrf plus good script.........dream combo. Race3 can be a blockbuster but hgoty....i have my doubts.

answered by Cinematographer (93k points)

If salman does race 3 then toh will have 50% chances to b hgoty coz thugs is not any content movie it is actioner just like race 3 or dhoom it will have only blood shed and nothing else

Tanveer, personally I feel salman should not do race3. Abbas mustan are good at ripping off hollywood movies, content hoga nahi khaas. Regarding toh, it is based on a novel called confessions of a thug by Phillip Meadows Taylor, proper story hogi bhai.

+1 vote

Aamir in a full on commercial movie is any day a better chances to score over others so i am sure that the TOH will be the HGOTY , not only the lifetime even the opening will be record breaking.

answered by Director (124k points)

Opening To Race 3 Ki Rahengi
Full Confident Hai

No chance Screenshot le lo TOH Opening > Salman 2018 film opening..
Only thing comparison should be valid only if they both release on non holiday or holiday..


Jo Hona Hai Woh Hokar Rahega

+1 vote

If Both Movie Same Equation
Content+Free Week
No Doubt Race 3 50-70 cr More
Compare To TOH
Before Release
My Bet
Because Amir Khan Choose Good Script

answered by Location Manager (5.3k points)
+1 vote

Right now, Aamir khan in full commercial release in bigger than anything else except Bahubali kind of thing.

So my vote goes to ToH

answered by Location Manager (7.7k points)
edited by
+1 vote

Definitely ToH.. You are never sure about the content of Race3, ToH having Aamir so it would be good in the worst case.

answered by Director (133k points)
+1 vote

i want this whole thing to be spiced up a little more....... i want a thugs of hindostan vs race 3 clash..... i dont care if industry loses 500-1000-50000000000 crore

but wait....

what if race 3 ... also has great supporting cast as well?? like salman khan hero sanjay dutt villain katrina kaif heroine

both solo movies..... it'll be tough competition.... and everything will boil down to content .... as opening of both movies will be historic

only murugadoss can do justice to a race movie with salman khan in it.

as of now.... both TOH release date is uncertain and so is race 3.

answered by Director (138k points)

Katrina race 1 mein Baghwan ko pyaari hogaye thi.

0 votes

I will put my money on TOH.

answered by Production Designer (13.1k points)
0 votes

Only thinking of Tiger Zinda Hain as of now

answered by Unit Manager (31.1k points)
0 votes

Well both movies have bad directors, but ToH will have more time to prepare and perfect itself so I would go with ToH, though the reshooting stuff has made me doubt it's​ prospects.

answered by Production Accountant (27k points)
0 votes

Race 3 with right treatment & scale would take around 9 months means it will either target Xmas 18 or 2019.

answered by Production Accountant (20.5k points)

Related questions

+3 votes
1 answer 181 views
181 views asked in Movie Discussions by being_tanveer Casting Director (17.9k points)
+2 votes
7 answers 278 views
278 views asked in Movie Discussions by being_tanveer Casting Director (17.9k points)
+3 votes
10 answers 467 views