+6 votes
asked in Opinion by All Time best! (291k points)
88% Accept Rate

4 Answers

0 votes
Best answer

Shad ali....
Shad directed 3 movies out of which I liked 2:-Sathiya and Bunty aur babli although he went horribly wrong with jbj..
In comparison sid directed 5 movies and out of all only saaam namaste was good and rest were average...
Sid is more focused on Youth and Style whereas shad is content oriented...
Overall Shaad is Anyday better than Sid ..

answered by Producer (113k points)
selected by
shaad ali was an assistant of Mani Ratnam. Saathiya is a remake of Mani Ratnam classic Alaipayuthey. And its also the first film Mani Ratnam chose not to dub it and sold the remake rights. Anyway, shaad Ali with exception of jbj and probably kill dill (i didnt like the song promos) is a better director.
He also assisted in Dil se guru Ravan also na??
Regarding kill dil even I am having same feeling...
Cannot comment on movie but almost all songs are very bad...
Didn't expect such from SEL.....
Yes he was AD for dilse, guru, raavan.
0 votes

I am a huge fan of Bunty aur Babli....So going with Shaad

answered by Second Unit Director (76k points)
0 votes

Sid Anand is better then Shaad as Sid's film are more youth oriented.

answered by Editor (80.3k points)
0 votes

Shaad Ali Hands down......!

answered by Assistant Director (48.1k points)

Related questions

+4 votes
2 answers 97 views
97 views asked Jul 11, 2014 in Opinion by Baazigar All Time best! (291k points)
+8 votes
1 answer 55 views
55 views asked Jul 22, 2014 in Opinion by sunny89 Location Manager (6.9k points)
+6 votes
3 answers 99 views
99 views asked Jun 14, 2014 in Opinion by Baazigar All Time best! (291k points)